457 Fire Island Boulevard, Fire Island Pines, NY 11782

$1,250,000

Looking for the perfect Fire Island Pines escape? This quintessential 1950s beach house offers a rare and irresistible combination of vintage charm, thoughtful modern updates, and distinctive style. It’s the ultimate summer getaway—and a savvy investment, with strong rental history and impressive cashflow potential! The open-plan living and dining area… Read More is anchored by a handsome wood-burning fireplace with its original cedar surround, infusing the space with character and warmth. A spacious, updated kitchen with sleek stainless steel appliances flows effortlessly into the entertaining area, which opens through a wall of glass onto the sun-splashed private deck and patio beyond. The main floor features three air-conditioned bedrooms and three full bathrooms, including a light-filled corner primary suite. Ample closet space is found throughout, with plenty of space for your hats, gloves and shoes–or whatever you may need.. Downstairs, a large and airy windowed bonus room opens to its own secluded deck—ideal as a guest lounge, creative studio, or media den. The adjacent laundry and storage rooms offer ample potential to add an additional bathroom (and even a kitchenette), transforming the level into a complete guest suite. Step outside to discover a true outdoor oasis: designer furnishings arranged around a chic oval plunge pool, a private hot tub nestled among the trees, and a gracious dining area perfect for al fresco meals under the stars. And of course, an outdoor shower for that quintessential beach house experience. Above it all, the expansive roof deck offers a fully appointed sanctuary for soaking up the sun by day—or experiencing the unforgettable Pines sunsets. Once owned by legendary director and choreographer Bob Fosse and his wife, the brilliant actress Joan McCracken—who spent her final years here—this home carries an illustrious legacy of Broadway brilliance. From Oklahoma! to Cabaret, Chicago to Sweet Charity, the creative spirit of these two icons still echoes through the walls of this enchanting retreat. Originally sited on Ocean Walk, the house was relocated in the 1990s to its current position atop one of the highest and most secure dunes in the Pines. Elevated on new foundation pilings and nestled along the quiet, wooded enclave of the “Burma Road,” the property offers rare privacy, peace of mind, and sweeping 180-degree bay views from the roof deck above. Rich in history, style, and serenity, this extraordinary home is a timeless retreat in one of Fire Island’s most sought-after settings. Comes complete with a Polaris vehicle for quick trips to the harbor. Act now—summer in the Pines awaits! Read Less

Listing Courtesy of Bank Neary Inc, 212-633-2727.

Listing Snapshot

Days Online

Last Updated

Jul 3, 2025

Property Type

Single Family Residence

Beds

Full Baths

Year Built

1958

MLS Number

879097

30 Days Snapshot Of 11782

$722k

-2%

(avg) sold price

+70%

homes sold

105

+43%

(avg) days on market

Snapshot

Area Map

Additional Details

Appliances & Equipment

Description: "Dishwasher", "Dryer", "Range", "Refrigerator", "Stainless Steel Appliance(s)", "Washer"

Basement

Description: "Finished", "Storage Space", "Walk-Out Access"

Building

Area: 0, Architecture: "Contemporary", "Mid-Century Modern", Construction Materials: "Wood Siding", Year Built: 1958

Cooling

Details: "Wall/Window Unit(s)"

Heating

Heating: "Other"

Lot

Acres: 0.14

Pool

Private Pool

Utilities

Sewer: "Septic Tank", Water Source: "Public", Utilities: "See Remarks"

Find The Perfect Home

'VIP' Listing Search

Whenever a listing hits the market that matches your criteria you will be immediately notified.

Join The List

Mortgage Calculator

Selling price

Down payment

Term (years)

Interest rate (%)

Monthly Payment

457 Fire Island Boulevard

'VIP' Listing Search

Schools In The Area

Similar Listings

Find My Dream Home

1. Neighborhoods

2. Home Type

3. Send